Toward mending the marine mass balance model for nickel: Experimentally determined isotope fractionation during Ni sorption to birnessite

In fewer than fifteen years, the study of Ni stable isotopes has advanced from early method development to application of a powerful tool for resolving a long-standing question: why does it appear that output fluxes of Ni from the global oceans far exceed input fluxes? The seawater concentration of Ni, a bioessential trace metal, is almost certainly at steady state on timescales comparable to its residence time of ∼20 kyr, so some of the current flux estimates must be inaccurate. Just as the input and output fluxes should balance, so should the flux-weighted isotopic compositions of the inputs and outputs. Thus, isotopic characterization of inputs and outputs provide an additional constraint on a balanced model of the marine Ni budget. Here, we report on experiments designed to elucidate fractionation mechanisms and magnitudes for sorption of Ni to Mn oxyhydroxide (birnessite), because Mn-rich sediments accumulating on abyssal plains represent the largest sink flux of Ni from seawater to marine sediments. Our results show remarkably large fractionations at low ionic strength (average Δ^60/58Ni_{dissolved-sorbed} = +1.38 ‰). Neither closed-system equilibrium trends nor Rayleigh curves fit the data well. Fractionations are even larger at high ionic strength (Δ^60/58Ni_{dissolved-sorbed} ranging from +2.0 to +4.0 ‰), and they decrease with experimental duration from 2 d (49 h) to 27 d. The high ionic strength data fit Rayleigh trends well. Here, we use X-ray absorption fine-structure spectroscopy (EXAFS) and results from previous studies to support interpretation of our data as combinations of kinetic and equilibrium isotope effects that vary in their proportional contributions to the total fractionation with time and with surface loading. One important consequence of this study is that none of the experimental results reported thus far, including ours, are directly applicable to building steady-state models of the Ni cycle. Even our longest duration experiments did not achieve equilibrium, which is likely to be manifest in the very slowly accumulating sediments on abyssal plains. Our work constrains further the mechanisms of Ni sorption to birnessite and clearly indicates that determination of equilibrium fractionation in this system, although challenging, will be a crucial step toward resolving the apparent marine Ni imbalance.