Biomass carbon stock and allocation of planted and natural forests in the Loess Plateau of China

Establishing planted forests (PF) by afforestation and naturally regenerating forests (NF) are important measures of enhance carbon (C) sequestration in terrestrial ecosystems. However, the difference of biomass C stocks and allocation between NF and PF and their determinants in water-limited areas remain unclear. To address this gap, we conducted a synthesis of above-ground biomass C (AGBC), below-ground biomass C (BGBC) stocks and root to shoot ratios (R:S) of PF and NF in the Chinese Loess Plateau. The changes in biomass C stock and R:S along a climate gradient were investigated, and the relationships between R:S and soil properties were also quantified. We found that PF exhibited lower AGBC and BGBC stocks compared to NF, but the average R:S in PF was significantly higher than that of NF (0.48 ± 0.27 vs. 0.30 ± 0.11, p < 0.05). Turning points existed in biomass C allocation along climatic gradient for both PF and NF. More biomass C was allocated to AGBC in PF and NF when mean annual precipitation exceeded 494 mm and 588 mm, respectively. Higher mean annual temperature promoted larger C allocations to BGBC in PF compared to NF. Soil properties had a stronger effect on the biomass C allocation patterns after afforestation, but to a lesser extent on NF. This study indicates that afforestation promotes a larger allocation of biomass C into the below-ground compared to naturally regenerated forests, and using the default R:S estimates may result in a severe underestimation of below-ground C stocks in water-limited areas. The biomass C stocks and allocation are collectively determined by climate conditions and soil properties, and accumulated below-ground biomass C stock induced by dryland afforestation may be an important C sink at a broad geographic scale.